Home/Dilemmas/ROI & Worth-It
💰 ROI & Worth-It

What percentage of students at Tier 1.5 and Tier 2 MBA colleges in India are IIT graduates?

mixedneutralbrand valueprestige preservationROI

IITians comprise a very small percentage of batches at Tier 1.5 and Tier 2 MBA colleges in India — and from what we've tracked across student conversations, this isn't surprising once you understand the underlying logic.

The picture that emerges is consistent: most IITians target either the top 6 IIMs (Ahmedabad, Bangalore, Calcutta, Delhi, Indore, Kozhikode) or prestigious non-IIM institutions like XLRI, FMS, and ISB. Tier 1.5 colleges — MICA, XIM, SCMHRD — and Tier 2 colleges like FORE, IMT-G, and TAPMI are rarely on their radar as genuine destinations. The presence, where it exists at all, tends to be exceptional rather than structural. We've come across mentions of an IIT BHU graduate attending GIM some decades ago, and occasional BITSians — not IITians — appearing at IMI or SCMHRD. These are outliers, not patterns.

The reasoning involves both brand arithmetic and career pragmatism. In our experience, IITians think carefully about institutional tier sequencing. Moving from an 'A+' category undergraduate institution like an IIT to an 'A' category MBA program is widely seen as diluting rather than building on a personal brand. The return on investment, the time commitment, and the peer quality at Tier 1.5 and Tier 2 programs don't justify that trade-off for someone already holding India's most prestigious engineering credential.

It's worth noting a sharper version of this view that we've heard from experienced professionals in this space: even admission to the newer IIMs carries a degree of reputational hesitation among IITians — captured bluntly in the phrase 'kar li beizzati' (a sense of prestige lost). For many in this cohort, an international MBA becomes a more attractive alternative to settling for a lower-ranked domestic program. An IIT Kanpur graduate, the logic goes, wouldn't realistically consider IIM Amritsar — the career outcomes and job market positioning simply don't justify the move.

What this creates is a natural talent stratification in Indian MBA admissions. Tier 1.5 and Tier 2 colleges draw their strength from strong non-IIT engineering backgrounds, commerce graduates, and working professionals — not from the premium engineering talent pipeline that the top-tier institutions compete for. This isn't a weakness in those batches so much as a reflection of how prestige hierarchies structure choices at every level of the system.

Wrestling with your own MBA decision?

Check your eligibility across 250+ colleges, or compare options side-by-side.

Check eligibility →Compare colleges

More dilemmas about IIM Ahmedabad

Why didn't I get IIM admission with 97 percentile CAT score in EWS category despite good interview performance?

IIM AhmedabadIIM Bangalore

Is CAT MBA worth pursuing if you have a low academic profile, and what are realistic college expectations for GEM candidates with high CAT scores?

IIM AhmedabadIIM Bangalore

How did an XLRI graduate with average academics (7/6/7 GNEM) secure a dream tier company placement after MBA?

XLRI JamshedpurIIM Ahmedabad

Is ISB experiencing significant placement issues with 80 unplaced students in recent batches?

ISBIIM Ahmedabad

Related dilemmas in ROI & Worth-It

How should an MBA graduate respond to a low-paying internship offer after experiencing placement failures?

Tier-II IIM (implied CAPs: Calcutta, Ahmedabad, Pune, Indore, Ranchi, Trichy, Udaipur, Raipur)NMIMS

How did an XLRI graduate with average academics (7/6/7 GNEM) secure a dream tier company placement after MBA?

XLRI JamshedpurIIM Ahmedabad

What is it like to study at XLRI Delhi? Placements, campus life, and how it compares to JSR and other top MBA colleges

XLRI DelhiXLRI Jamshedpur

Why am I unable to switch jobs 4 years after completing my MBA despite active job hunting?

IIM Ahmedabad (implied as BLACKI)IIM Indore (implied as BLACKI)